Study on Economic Models to Prevent the Transport of Unfit End-of-career Dairy Cows

Download or read book Study on Economic Models to Prevent the Transport of Unfit End-of-career Dairy Cows written by and published by . This book was released on 2022 with total page pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: European law (Council Regulation (EC) No 1/2005 on the protection of animals during transport and related operations) requires that any 'unfit' animals shall not be considered for transport. This includes animals that are injured or that present physiological weaknesses or pathological processes. The regulation is intended to prevent injury or unnecessary suffering to animals when being transported between countries in the European Union (EU). Nevertheless, some unfit end-of-career dairy cows are transported to slaughterhouses. This study has been undertaken to identify drivers for this practice and options to help improve the conditions and welfare of end-of-career cows. The study looks at the scale of the problem, identifies reasons for non-compliance, documents which mitigation measures have been put in place to address the issue and identifies best practices. This involved the following research tasks: desk review on a range of topics important to the assessment; exploratory interviews with experts to gather initial ideas regarding the study; two online surveys, targeting national competent authorities (NCAs) and industry representative organisations, to capture their views and gather data; 34 qualitative interviews with various stakeholder groups in nine Member States (MS) and at EU-level; case studies on nine key study themes affecting end-of-career cows and their transportation; and a validation survey, sent to stakeholders to confirm or dispute the evidence gathered throughout the study and included in the report. The study finds that assessing the overall magnitude of the transportation of unfit end-of-career cows is difficult, due to data not being consistently collected and the illegal nature of the issue. Nevertheless, some evidence was collected indicating the issue does occur in the EU and several possible reasons for non-compliance were identified. Evidence from the desk research, surveys and interviews indicated that economic factors are a major cause explaining why unfit cows are transported. The drivers here are numerous, working through several channels. This includes the lower cost of transporting cows to slaughterhouses, compared to slaughtering on-farm (where available); the financial gain from selling the carcass, exacerbated by low returns across the EU dairy sector; and many existing sanctions being insufficient to deter illegal activity. Furthermore, social factors are found to play a role, including peer pressure among stakeholders within the supply chain and expectations regarding dairy cow welfare and lifespan (the economic model). Issues with interpretating or understanding the definition of 'unfit' were also identified, with stakeholders incorporating different factors when making the decision whether to transport a cow. In regard to mitigation measures, the study found best practice and transport guidelines are among the most common measures already in place and are viewed positively by stakeholders. Quality assurance schemes, which primarily focus on preventing cows from becoming unfit, could be further promoted by the dairy industry. NCAs frequently use cautions, warnings, and fines when cows are found to have been transported but this is uneven. Sanctions must be sufficiently large and well enforced so that stakeholders believe they will be imposed, to deter poor practice and illegal activity. There is evidence to suggest industry initiatives could be effective if combined with more stringent controls, including more frequent investigations that are not prewarned. These actions need to work alongside better awareness and training for farmers and widespread access to slaughtering on-farm. Mandatory CCTV systems could support this, although such initiatives are relatively new so evidence on their effectiveness is limited. Wider actions to address systemic issues such as the low margin economic model for milk production and a lack of information for consumers on the welfare of dairy cows should also be seen as part of addressing the problem of transporting unfit cows at end of life.